In my opinion you have to set up some standards which can solve a lot of problems in futer. About ban you are decide act on private feelings. Peak of stupidity was broken in Lemonade case. Caught 17 times with cheat under own Ip and guid and till now he is free to play on WM servers including our team speak. Rules are different depend of who broken them. Sometimes our admins ban cause of cursing and we let play someone who is proved cheater. Same topic with HelloKity who even fucked public our reputation on cod 4 area. Even after that incident he continued game on WM server. Some period ago you asked to connect our server to base with banned guids but cause of lack technical possibility we left that idea.
I dont know if ABC cheated or not but for sure I know one thing. If his guid isn't clean than it should be banned on WM. Poeple are charge of own pc, cd key and it is up to them what they are doing with it but they have to understood they will pay consequences. Not their cousins, neighbours, younger brother or dog. Like that we can unban each guy with good story.
Poeple cheat everywhere politic, sport , life and as well in games. Exist many kind of cheaters. Some of them are easy to caught cause they begging with cheat some represent already some skill and abusing it not so obviously. In that fight between cheaters and admins Im more than sure in among of banned you eliminated very skilled players.
You have to admit that our clan or community (call it whatever you wish) playing cod for fun and not many of you represent high level in game. What I wanna say is in some case you cant judge cause lack of experience. That why we shouldn't ingore game violation and other that kind of service and simple ban such a guids. Usually you are trying to base on last 5 min of spec but remember "poeple are not like their last conversation" If someone cheated and got busted exist big possibility she/he will try again. Imagine if someone discover something what is undetectable by PB. Such a players are first to using it.
Right now our cod ship dont rly have captain. 1 of admins ban someone cause of guid note and other thinking about unban. Make some decisions if you care about history guid or not. Or maybe it depend of sad story and talent orator who make request on wm forum about unban.
There is some things which I cant understood. Why poeple who are playing couple years cod4 , spend on it lets say 10- 20 hours per week arent able to download tzac and register account which took at all I guess max 5 min. I mean even new poeple who apply here. We actually dont know eachother. Since I begun work I meet many dishonest poeple. I lead in past big community and even some poeple who were around 2,3 years got caught with cheats.
To make it clear I do not propose suspect everybody about cheats but you can eliminete many of them if you copy banned guids from game violations , starting using tzac, trying to adverst that program by for example text msg about that on wm game server.
SUM UP IF YOU ARE TO LAZY TO READ
in my opinion abc ban should stay on server and not cause suspicion he cheated but cause in 2009 that guid was banned !